Listen to this article
16 min
THE ART OF MENTORING: GUIDING THE NEXT GENERATION—AND PROTECTING WHAT WE’VE BUILT
BY HEIDI KILGORE, MAPSY EVANSVILLE KENNEL CLUB CWCNRT REGIONAL REPRESENTATIVE
Sitting here thinking of all the court cases whirling in the regional headlines over the past couple of years, one question sticks out: Where were the mentors?
Starting in this sport over fifty years ago, I remember sitting around the potluck table in a group and having mentors—people who not only shared information but were an integral part of our sport and our lives. They weren’t bossy or restrictive. They openly shared decades of knowledge and the tricks of the trade that moved our breed and our sport forward. Each one of them brought a different perspective to the conversation. In truth, they hardly ever agreed with one another, but they also respected and listened. The days of the tailgating mentality at dog shows may be gone, simply due to the nature of our world, but the idea that mentors are no longer active and engaged in their dogs, generations after a placement, is surreal.
Every accomplished breeder, handler, and competitor in AKC sports can point to the people who shaped their journey. The mentor who explained why one dog moved better than another. The trainer who stayed after class to help troubleshoot a crooked front. The breeder who opened her whelping box and her pedigree files to a complete stranger with a sincere desire to learn. These relationships are the invisible infrastructure of our sport, and without them, we lose far more newcomers than we keep. The AKC’s updated Code of Sportsmanship and Civility specifically calls on competitors to actively support newcomers by serving as mentors and helping them to learn the rules, values, and traditions of the sport. But what does it actually mean to be a good mentor?
WHAT MENTORING REALLY MEANS
Mentoring is traditionally defined as the act or process of helping and guiding another person to support their personal development. That definition, simple as it sounds, opens a floodgate of questions. When does a person not need a mentor anymore? Is it when they’ve matched the knowledge of the person guiding them? Don’t they then need a new mentor to help them reach the next level?
In business, mentors are assigned every time you change positions or move up. The titles change—trainer, manager, director—but the basic principles of mentoring are embedded within them. As you advance through the structure, you switch or upgrade your mentors to meet your evolving needs, while the previous mentors remain because the foundational relationship is still strong.
The same principle applies in dogs. The AKC Exhibitor Mentoring Program establishes baseline requirements for approved mentors: membership in an AKC-affiliated club, good standing with the AKC, a minimum of six years of active involvement, a solid grasp of the rules and regulations, and a commitment to sportsmanlike conduct. For parent club-approved mentors involved in the judging approval process, individual breed clubs may set additional criteria around breeding experience, years exhibiting, or participation in Performance events.
Meeting those requirements, though, is only the threshold. The difference between a mentor who checks a box and one who genuinely transforms a newcomer’s experience lies in the qualities that no application form can measure.
THE HARD TRUTH ABOUT OUR CULTURE
In this subjective, opinionated sport, I have heard some say that we eat our own. In the hunt to win, we become highly competitive and cutthroat, turning on our own breed fanciers—publicly and privately humiliating them, driving them from the sport, or teaching them to be as ruthless as we are. This mentality and vindictiveness spreads across social media, is spoken ringside, and flows like lava, infiltrating every crevice of our culture. Just like lava, it breaks down the very foundations of our sport.
How do we change our approach to mentoring and start using it to protect our animals and our sport? The answer begins with a simple imperative: Be a mentor, and with that imperative comes a set of principles worth examining.
WITHHOLD JUDGMENT
You, as a mentor, have likely been in your breed a decade or two or three, or even more. If you sat down and looked back at where you came from—what your knowledge base was, how much you’ve changed and grown from that starting point—you would be amazed. Extend that same grace to the new people, whether they’re new to your breed or new to the sport entirely. They are sponges waiting to absorb your opinion and your reasoning. Don’t punish them for what they don’t yet know.
A breed-oriented mentor sees the big picture—the health, the structure, the temperament, the future of the breed as a whole. They can honestly assess the virtues and faults of dogs from any kennel, including their own, and find things to admire in a competitor’s program. A kennel-oriented mentor, by contrast, sees goodness only in their own line. They may discourage a mentee from talking to certain people, attending certain events, or forming their own opinions. That kind of gatekeeping may feel like loyalty, but it stunts growth and narrows a newcomer’s understanding of the breed before it has had a chance to develop.
REMEMBER THAT THIS SPORT IS SUBJECTIVE
We read our Breed Standards, we look at our dogs, we put them up for judging. There are so many minute details in every dog we evaluate that we cannot possibly know each and every one. Add to that the genetics of dogs, and it becomes a roulette game— every time we walk into the show ring, every time we deliver a puppy, every time we plan our next breeding and set goals to do a better job. Hold close that this is an opinion of a dog, based on passion and preference. It is subjective to the eye of the beholder.
The best mentors frame honest feedback within a context of encouragement: what the dog does well, what the handler is doing right, and specifically, what to work on next. They are truthful about a dog’s limitations without crushing the enthusiasm that brought the newcomer to the sport. When Conformation isn’t in the cards for a particular dog, a thoughtful mentor points the way to the many other AKC sports where that dog can shine.
COMMUNICATE—AND LISTEN FIRST
Communication is the cornerstone of any successful endeavor, and it has two parts. The first, and the most important, is listening. When you truly hear the other person, you can feel their frustrations, their exhaustion, their triumphs, and their depression. In our culture of instant gratification and competitiveness—where professional handlers work multiple breeds across several venues, and social media posts and public records fuel judgment—a mentor who listens is a lifeline.
Does your mentee sound flustered and overwhelmed? Make the time to show up personally and help them work through the hurdle. Are they a trainer and supposed to be the expert? No one knows your dogs better than you. Mentor or not: listen, and hear where you might be supportive.
The second part is conversation—not being bossy, but meeting someone where they are and helping them move to the next stage of their plan. In doing so, you will often find your own plans move forward too. Generosity of time and knowledge is not a one-way street; the best mentoring relationships flow in both directions.
BE OPEN TO LEARNING AND GROWING
Respect your limits. People new to anything have a dedicated interest and are going to research, learn, and grow their knowledge base— through scientific journals, through decades of published works on the subject, and increasingly, through sources that are completely shaped by the mentors around them. That means, as a mentor, you have to keep researching, looking at different information, and adapting. There is a real difference between someone with twenty years of experience and someone with one year of experience repeated twenty times.
In Conformation, that depth includes Breed Standard interpretation, structural soundness, movement, coat and grooming, conditioning, and reproductive health. In Performance sports—Obedience, Rally, Agility, Scent Work, Tracking, and the many others that AKC sanctions—it means staying current with rules, training methodology, and an understanding of how different dogs learn. A mentor who stopped learning ten years ago is teaching outdated information. Rules change. Training science evolves. Staying current is not optional.
You also have to know when your mentee has tapped your knowledge and be willing to send them to those who have more to offer—and to support that transition. Think of it like moving from the front office to a supervisory or managerial position: the previous mentors are still there, but new ones are needed for the next stage.
CELEBRATE
In the search for that major, that final point, that elusive goal, we as exhibitors tend to forget to celebrate those who won when we didn’t. We spend the day grooming, running around the ring, returning for the second and third times. Our adrenaline is up, our expectations are unreasonable, and our reactions are strong. We justify the loss as a judge’s error or nitpick the dog that won.
I have personally experienced my mentor not celebrating with me because they didn’t win. Comments like, “Well, did you see what they put up? That was complete crap”—completely undermining my win on my dog with a single statement. Why? Because they lost.
So please, above all else, celebrate. In this sport, I was taught a long time ago that it is the dog on that day with that judge. Celebrate the wins of others. Truly feel their joy. Model the sportsmanship you want to see—because newcomers watch everything. They observe how you react to a loss, how you speak about the judge, how you treat the people around you at ringside and online. If you disparage fellow competitors, trash-talk judges, or throw a leash in frustration, you are teaching your mentee that this behavior is normal. It is not.
THINK BEYOND YOUR OWN RING
AKC sports have never been more diverse: Conformation, Obedience, Rally, Agility, Scent Work, Barn Hunt, Fast CAT, Dock Diving, Herding, Tracking—the list keeps growing, and so does the community of people participating. A mentor grounded solely in Conformation may miss the opportunity to encourage a newcomer whose dog would excel in Performance events. A Performance mentor who dismisses the show ring overlooks a fundamental piece of breed preservation.
The most valuable mentors have a broad view of what the AKC offers and can guide newcomers toward the sports that match their dogs, their interests, and their goals. Even if your own expertise is narrow, knowing who to refer a mentee to is itself a form of mentoring.
KNOW WHEN TO PASS THE TORCH
Mentoring does not last forever—and it is not supposed to. Take the time to find the very first Standard written for your breed, then look at the most current. Look at all of them if you can and watch how knowledge, application, medical and genetic information, and people have changed your breed to develop a healthier, better dog. Change is caused by exploration and adventure. In the world of dogs, it has created longer, healthier lives. In the 1970s, an Irish Wolfhound was expected to live under ten years; now they are living longer. The ideas of the 1970s have been revised to improve our breeds, just as intended.
The proper guidance of a mentee, the ability to recognize when you have exhausted your experience and knowledge, and the willingness to introduce them to new people with new ideas—even if you don’t agree with them or see their value—is paramount to being a mentor and paramount to keeping our sport thriving. A mentor’s ultimate success is not measured by how long the mentee depends on them but by how effectively the mentee learns to stand on their own.
It is also entirely normal for a mentee to add new mentors over time—one for breeding advice, another for grooming, a third in a different breed to broaden their understanding of structure and movement. This is not a betrayal. It is growth, and a good mentor celebrates it.
IT IS NOT ABOUT EGO
Understand that being a mentor is not for the ego. It is not about being the absolute authority or even about being right. The responsibility of the mentor is to guide, train, and support someone in the sport, in breeding, and in our culture—without judgment or opinions that are unwavering and absolute. As a mentor, you will see things in your breed that are completely against everything you believe in and everything you personally know. Knowing that, you must teach by example, using graciousness and education and research to provide the tools your mentee needs to succeed.
A successful mentor puts themselves out of a job and can sit back and celebrate the successes of those who trusted them to begin with.
THE FUTURE DEPENDS ON IT
Our sport faces real challenges: aging demographics, declining entries at many shows, and a generation of potential newcomers who often feel intimidated by a community they perceive as insular. The pragmatic truth is that the future of purebred dogs—the breeds we love, the events we cherish, the clubs we sustain—depends on dedicated newcomers being welcomed, guided, and retained.
Some mentors burn out. Bad experiences with ungrateful protégés leave them bitter. The wisest among us understand that one difficult experience should not close the door to the next sincere newcomer who just needs someone to show them the way.
When a giving mentor pairs up with a sincere newcomer, the results can be remarkable: road trips to Nationals, shared breeding programs, lifelong friendships, and— most importantly—another person who will someday pay it forward by mentoring someone new. The ribbons we win today are quickly forgotten. The knowledge we share and the relationships we nurture last beyond our lifetimes.
If you have the experience, the temperament, and the willingness—be a mentor. And if you are looking for one, don’t be afraid to ask. The best people in our sport got where they are because someone, once, took the time to help them.
Happy mentoring.