Thomas Coen reflects on judging Bred-By-Exhibitor Best in Show at the 2025 AKC National Championship and today’s breeders.

The Weekly Brief
The best of SHOWSIGHT editorials, weekly wins, and breeder commentary — delivered to your inbox every Sunday morning.
Thomas Coen: As a breeder for more than fifty years, this invitation meant a great deal to me. I was deeply honored and also aware of the responsibility that comes with this special assignment.
Thomas Coen: To me, to be invited to judge at this special AKC show was a validation of my six decades as a breeder, handler, and judge.
Thomas Coen: First, the size of the show, with all its events, is mind-boggling, especially when you think of how many clubs are struggling with lower entries. Not only were the numbers incredible, but the quality was deep. Seeing dogs of such excellence is inspiring and an education in itself.
Thomas Coen: I was anxious to see the finalists make their first trip around the ring.
Thomas Coen: There definitely was a heightened energy coming from the dogs, their handlers, and the spectators. More than that, though, I felt the incredible sense of pride from the breeder/handlers and every dog rose to the occasion.
Thomas Coen: This was one of those rare assignments where the quality was so high and all the dogs were very deserving. Thank you to the BBE Group judges for sending me such outstanding dogs.
Thomas Coen: My Best BBE winner, the Smooth Fox Terrier, possesses beautiful breed type and real quality both standing and in motion. He is very special and a credit to his breeder.
Thomas Coen: Based on this assignment and these dogs, the breeders are doing a great job! That being said, there are too many assignments where the quality is disappointing and it makes me wonder if the breeders/exhibitors have done their homework and studied the Breed Standard for their own breed.
Thomas Coen: It’s actually mind-boggling to think of how many details are involved in planning a show of this size with such a variety of events offered. “Thank you” to the AKC and Royal Canin definitely seems insufficient for a show of this magnitude. KUDOS FOR A GREAT JOB!
Thomas Coen: When I think about 2025, the shows that come to mind are The Garden, the Collie National Specialty, Morris and Essex, and the AKC National Championship. I would rather see fewer shows with higher attendance and deeper quality. Keeping the bar high should be a definite priority.
American Kennel Club (AKC)