Judging The Border Terrier

Robert and Ruth Ann Naun discuss judging the Border Terrier

From Ruth Ann

A judge of the Border Terrier will stay on breed standard if they hold to the rule that form follows function. Bred by working farmers in the Cheviot Hills of Northumberland in England, and the southern Scottish border country, this breed went out with hounds in this wild hilly countryside. Therefore, the Border Terrier should be built to cover long distances over an extended period on the day of hunting, in all sorts of weather. Once the fox they chase goes to ground, the Border Terrier goes in and finishes its work of the day, or flushes the fox for others to dispatch. Every breed trait judged in confirmation, still should reference this function.

Exhibitors will respect the judge who attempts to evaluate entries base on this approach. Bob Naun explores the standard point by point, in what follows here. He gives a prospective that has been previously published in this magazine. He has clearly outlined the evaluating that takes in the whole dog using this approach. Border Terriers can still do the work they were bred to do. The Border Terrier community and the breed’s parent club hold a desire to see a functioning working Border Terrier in the show ring. When those traits put a Border Terrier in the ribbons in your ring, you can safely feel a good job was done of judging this breed.

From Robert

Many judges have difficulty in judging the Border Terrier because of the emphasis on function as a working terrier. Most terrier standards put more emphasis upon appearances, with the exception of the Parson Russell Terrier.

In Britain in the earliest written standard of the breed we have (1920), and in the American standard in the early 1940s, this emphasis was in the Border Terrier standard. Dr. Merritt Pope, the prime mover in working towards recognition of the breed in the US and his friend Mr. William McBain, were disturbed by changes made to the Scottish Terrier standard for the purpose of improving its chances for winning in the show ring.

For Dr. Pope, a well-designed and functional machine was a beautiful thing to observe, and they wanted to apply this concept to the functional purposefulness of a terrier. He and his committee were attempting to design the perfect working terrier in a breed standard. They abhorred the fancy terriers they were seeing in the show ring.

The descriptive terms they used to describe the Border Terrier are few in number. They wanted a head that resembled that of an otter, in particular a river otter head. They wanted a dog who would be spannable by a man’s hands, a method used by old time hunters to evaluate the ability of a dog to go to ground. They consistently talked about the Borders’ ability to run with horses and to get along with hounds. Given this, the Border should not spar.

For working terriers, the ribs should not be over sprung. They should have ribs well back with a flexible loin which would allow the terrier to turn around more easily when down the hole after the fox, this also helps to give more stamina to a dog doing a days’ work.

Finally, they wanted a double-coated dog who could work under the hard conditions of the English/Scottish border country, and not a fancy smooth coated terrier.

When beginning to judge the Border Terrier in the show ring, the judge should observer the Border outline. It is on the table that the judge can begin to evaluate the functioning ability of the Border to work. Approaching from the front the judge should be looking for shoulders that are smooth and relatively narrow. The space between the legs should not be narrower than that of the Fox Terrier— “approximately 3″ or 3 fingers” and no larger than 4″ (approximately four fingers). The Border’s legs should be straight and not turned in or out. He should not be loaded in shoulders which would interferes with is going to ground.

Looking at the head itself, there should be very little stop with proportions of 2 to 1 from the occiput to stop with the muzzle one-third to tip. It is moderately broad and flat with plenty of width between the eyes and the ears. A slight, moderately broad slope at the stop rather than a pronounce indentation. The muzzle is short and well filled. The ears should be in proportion to the head, v-shaped and moderately thick with dark ears preferred. (Some judges cover the ears when examining the head to get a better view of an otter like head.) The ear breaks below the level of skull and should be in proportion to the head.

The Border’s eyes are dark and moderate in size with fill under the eyes. Its strong masseter muscles gave the Border a cheeky appearance. Too short a muzzle will produce bulging eye, á la the Brussels Griffon. The Border’s nose is black and of a good size. The Border’s teeth have a scissors bite with no deviation allowed, large for the size of the dog.

The Border Terrier neck is well set on and long enough to allow the freedom of head movement. The Border Terrier shoulder blades are long and well laid back with the length of the shoulder blade and upper arm being approximately equal and converging at the withers.

The space between the forelegs is equal at the elbows and at the feet. The length and angulation of the shoulder and upper arm results in the legs being set further back and under the withers rather than as in the Fox Terrier—giving the Border a somewhat chesty look when viewed from the side. Unlike the Fox Terrier and other fancy terrier breeds, the Border has a somewhat strait underline.

To properly evaluate terrier’ ability to go to ground, it must be spannable. To span a terrier a judge must place his hands behind the elbows, raising only the front from the table, compressing the chest gently. Ideally, his thumbs should meet at the spine and his fingers should meet under the terrier.

Dr. Pope called the Border the “the smallest tall, long-legged terrier”. This was necessary for his working in the border between England and Scotland in order to be able to keep up with the horse and the hounds over rough ground. A shortlegged, over-sprung, wide, deep chested Border would not be able to do the work he was bred to do. Border dogs should weigh 13-15½ pounds, bitches, 11½-14 pounds in hardworking condition. It is rare now, in the era of couch potatoes and expensive dog foods, to find a Border in the hard working condition previously seen in the working terriers in the Border country. Proportions should be the height at the withers is slightly greater than the distance from the withers to the base of the tail, by about 1″-1½”.

The same rough terrain and climate requires a double coat for protection on the job. The tweedy broken coat is preferred. A lack of undercoat must be faulted. The coat should be hard and wiry. There must be evidence of a double coat. If there is no evidence, it must be assumed it does not exist. Borders should never be overly trimmed to resemble other breeds. Excessive grooming should be penalized.

A useful tool for the working Border is his tail, shaped like a carrot, thick at base and tapering to a point. It is often used by the huntsman to pull the Border out of the foxhole. Ideally it comes off the back at a fortyfive degree angle, but upright, or level carriage, is also acceptable, but never over the back.

The topline of the Border is not mentioned in the standard. The original drafts of the standard spoke about a slight rise over the loin. The drafters, fearing that judges would exaggerate this phrase. The prohibition of a dip behind the withers was the only comment put in the standard about the topline.

The Border is the only terrier that has a loose and thick fitting skin (hide or pelt). This is crucial because it protects the dog from injury inflicted by his quarry, other dogs or underbrush. The judge should not hesitate to grasp a handful of skin in back of the shoulders and lift it.

The Border’s rear is muscular, thighs long, stifles well bent and hocks well let down. Rear angulation should be complimentary to that of the front.

The Border Terrier coat can come in red, grizzle and tan, blue and tan and wheaten. None are preferred as function is not affected, however altering coat color and trimming with scissors are not appropriate for a working terrier.

  • Ruth Ann Naun is a specialist judge of Border Terriers since 1992. She has judged the national specialty twice and the breed at CC level in Britain twice as well. She is the long time delegate of the Border Terrier Club of America to the AKC. Bob Naun, her husband, died in late 2011, was a Terrier Group judge, and had held posts in the parent club including president for fifteen years, and club historian. He had also judged the breed national twice and was the first American to award CCs in their breed in Britain. Their Oldstone prefix has been a presence in the breed since the early 1970s.

  • Show Comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

You May Also Like

Judging the Skye terrier

From the February 2019 Issue of ShowSight. Click to subscribe.  Photo’s courtesy of The ...

A Guide to Examining & Judging The Shih Tzu

Judging the Shih Tzu can be a challenging task for the newly approved Breed ...

Breeders Have A Story To Tell

From the monthly column "BECOMING" by By Jacquelyn Fogel, ShowSight Magazine, October 2017 Issue I ...

Why does Sussex Spaniel look so sad ?

Why do Sussex Spaniels Look So Sad?

Why do Sussex Spaniels Look So Sad? - The AKC Breed Standard states: “The ...

Judging the Affenpinscher Toy Dog Breed at Dog Shows

Judging the Affenpinscher

When learning to evaluate the Affenpinscher it can be difficult for several reasons. It ...