Menu toggle icon.
Menu toggle icon.

It’s a Real Pain

Can. CH & OTCH Butterblac's Some Fools Dream Am. UD JH WCX; Can. WCI - "Bannor” (3/31/1985 – 5/14/1999)


It’s a Real Pain

“MAKE him do it!”

“He’s just giving you the doggie dewclaw!”

“Pick him up and throw him over the jump!”

These were some of the comments I heard as I tried to understand why my experienced Obedience dog would not jump the bar jump. This was a long time ago, but it is a lesson I have never forgotten.

“Bannor,” my beautiful Golden Retriever, was 9-1/2 years old and we were just coming off a winter break, hoping to obtain the last 15 points we needed to complete his American Obedience Trial Championship (OTCH). We had spent a long, frustrating 3-1/2 years garnering 85 OTCH points. Bannor was a great Obedience dog, but in those days, points were not awarded unless you placed first or second in the class, and every weekend we found ourselves competing against the Top 10 Obedience dogs in the country. I swear, I could drive into the parking lot and, after checking out the cars that were there, know whether we’d get points or not that weekend.

training problem
Can. CH & OTCH Butterblac’s Some Fools Dream Am. UD JH WCX; Can. WCI – “Bannor” (3/31/1985 – 5/14/1999)

That spring, whenever I set up the directed jumping exercise and signaled for Bannor to take the bar jump, he would run up to it and stop dead in his tracks. In those days, this 23-inch Golden had to jump a 34-inch bar jump! The weird thing was, if I walked up and tapped the bar, he would leap over the jump from a stand-still! Maybe that explained some of the comments made by bystanders at the training facility.

But I knew that this sweet boy didn’t have an oppositional bone in his body. If he could have jumped over the moon for me, he would have. At about that time, I was starting to have a little trouble seeing things up close, a condition called presbyopia that most people begin to experience in middle age. I couldn’t help wondering if Bannor was having trouble with his eyesight, especially with focusing on objects up close. Perhaps the black and white stripes of the bar jump added to his difficulty.

Even though Bannor had had clear ophthalmology examinations every year, I took him to an ophthalmologist and asked specifically about whether he might be having trouble focusing on close objects. The ophthalmologist confirmed my suspicions. Apparently, the two of us were aging together! And that was the end of our OTCH campaign. I would not ask him to do something that he was physically unable to comply with.

The message that I wish to convey with this personal story is very simple: if you ever have a training problem, always consider first whether there might be a physical reason.

Every week in my veterinary practice, I see clients that for weeks, often for months, and regretfully, sometimes for years, have struggled with a training problem, not recognizing that their dog was actually in pain. Perhaps the dog consistently missed weave pole entries, or struggled with the broad jump in Obedience, or just slowed down in Field Work, Tracking, or any other sport. It seems our first thought is always to try to figure out how we can retrain the exercise. The dog did it before—why can’t they do it now?

Well, it might just be because your dog hurts. If that’s the case, then all the training in the world isn’t going to change the problem, and continued training might just make it worse. When my clients finally learn that their dog has an injury or some other physical problem, they experience incredible sadness and regret that they tried to fix something with training when it could only be fixed through healing.

We know that most dogs won’t show evidence of pain until it is moderate to severe. If a dog were ever asked to describe its pain on a scale such as the 0-to-10 pain scale we are given at the ER, their numbers would be 0-0-0-0-0-0-6-7-8-9-10. Many painful conditions such as back pain, soft tissue injuries of the shoulder, or iliopsoas strain can have very subtle or even absent clinical signs.

So, if you ever find yourself facing a knotty training problem, even if your dog’s performance has just slowed a bit, or if you notice even a slightly reduced desire to play the game, stop training and immediately have your dog evaluated by a veterinarian. Start with your general practitioner, who already knows your dog and who will likely initiate important blood and other tests to rule out a variety of systemic illnesses. If nothing obvious is found, consider seeing a sports medicine or orthopedic specialist for further diagnostics to rule out a hidden musculoskeletal problem. These specialists can be identified by the letters DACVSMR or DACVS, respectively, after their name. That way you’ll be sure you aren’t asking your canine companion to do something that, while their heart is willing, their body is not able.

After saying good-bye to my OTCH aspirations, I was lucky to share my life with Bannor for another five years, and during that time we had many adventures that were much more fun than competing in Obedience. I came to realize that in giving him the registered name Butterblac’s Some Fools Dream, the universe had a different dream in mind.

We went for long hikes in the woods, we sat at the edge of a pond and contemplated the meaning of life (at least I did—I’m not sure what Bannor was thinking, but I am sure they were deep canine thoughts), and we just spent time together, being present. Dogs are so good at that.

If you ever have a training problem, always consider first whether there might be a physical reason.